As the one year trial period for bicycles sharing pedestrian pavements is coming to an end in May, the internet and newspaper forums are again peppered with articles about cyclists.
The usually letters of drivers complaining about cyclists on the road, and pedestrians complaining about cyclists on the pavements. While I will agree with most of these letters about the specific irresponsible individuals they encountered, it also shows how Singaporeans are intolerant and discriminating towards others. There is a clear lack of understanding between various socio-economic groups in Singapore.
I got a more poignant view of this situation because I have just began motorcycle lessons, and forays into motorcycle forums in Singapore. One of the recent news articles that was picked up by the motorcycle forum is an article about a higher risk of death to passengers riding pillion behind P-plated riders.
For those not familiar with Singapore, newly licensed drivers and riders here need to put a probational plate on their vehicle for the first year. This plate begs for understanding from fellow riders, and is a magnet for ridicule and insults should the driver makes a mistake.
Basically, the transport authorities in Singapore released some statistics about motorcycle accidents, and the big news is how passengers riding pillion are disproportionately more likely to die in an accident, particularly if the rider was newly licensed.
Of course, the usual Singapore reaction is for a call to ban newly licensed riders from carrying pillon passengers, which is probably not a wholly bad idea. There is also a suggestion to ban the use of cargo boxes behind the motorcycles for the same type of riders. I assume that there must be some statistics about how the balance of the motorcycle becomes an issue with a cargo box, but nothing as such was mentioned in the article.
This has got the some motorcycle riders angered, for a few reasons. About a month ago, there were two high profile traffic accidents involving cars driven by new drivers, which ended up with quite a few deaths. This gives motorcycle riders the ammunition to claim that if they cannot carry passengers, surely new car drivers should not either, perhaps rightly so.
This is compounded by the fact that motorcycles are by and large an economic choice in Singapore, as opposed to a lifestyle choice. The vast majority of motorcycle riders ride because it is the only affordable means of personal transport; cars in Singapore are notoriously high priced. As certain minority race groups tend to be on a lower income bracket, and thus have a higher proportionate representation in motorcycle riding, any rule that appears to discriminate against motorcycles will touch a raw nerve with certain minority races and lower income citizens.
I have written that car drivers in Singapore do not treat bicycle riders as equals on the roads here. And having gotten a closer look at motorcycle riders, I believe that they feel similarly treated.
For the above-mentioned economic and perhaps racial reasons, motorcycle riders seem to be discriminated against by more than just car drivers. There are complaints that no petrol station pump attendant ever helps a motorcycle rider pump petrol, despite the fact that they pay the same rate and usually use a higher octane petrol (apparently they get full service in Thailand’s petrol stations). Establishments such as shopping malls also are attacked for not supply motorcycle parking lots. Some go as far as to reject motorcycle riders even if they are willing to pay a full car parking rate.
They too suffer from attacks in the newspaper for parking their motorcycles on pavements illegally, which they refute as the results of establishments not having enough or any lots of motorcycles.
Singapores are intolerant to their fellow countrymen. They are just interested in others who lead the same lifestyle as them and take every opportunity to snipe at other groups. At the end of the day, everyone is just trying to get on with life and make ends meet, a little basic courtesy and understand helps.
I’m a P-plate motorbike rider and have seen my fair share of stupid drivers. Well I have also been driving for 10 years so I know how easy it is to be distracted while driving. A minor accident may just mean some dents to the car but to a rider, it could well be broken limbs or worse!
There have also been this stupid suggestion of limiting motorcycles to the extreme left lane on expressways… together with other heavy vehicles like trucks! None of those who came up with this stupid suggestion ever thought about how dangerous it is for motorbikes to ride in between trucks, whose drivers can hardly spot a puny motorbike in front of them.
Pedestrians are another culprit. They cross the road very close to you, thinking you have Valentino Rossi skills to ride within a hair’s width. Meanwhile you’re worried that they may just walk into your path, forcing you to do your e-brake.
Anyway, the funny thing is even though some drivers try to be funny, bikes usually accelerate faster than cars so take heart that you can make them smell your exhaust when the light turns green
What else can I say… pay full attention while riding and always be prepared to stop. And protective riding gear is important!
Looks like we are on similar boats. I have a Class 3 license for 12 years, and am still at Practical 5 for my Class 2B training.
There’s unsafe road users from all categories, the difference is that pedestrians, cyclists and motorcyclists by and large do it at their own risk, while car drivers are much more of a risk to both themselves and other road users. They are also the majority road user.
It is a matter of habit, with the vast majority of Singaporeans riding small bikes, they have a tendency to want to ride between vehicles. In countries where big bikes are more usual, most riders take up a full car space on the lanes and ride in line with the driver’s position.
Even though my scooter is only 200cc, I don’t ride in between cars (splitting lanes) except at traffic lights. I can’t split lanes very well and I’m also not confident of my e-brake. So I just don’t do it. So far nobody has given me grief. I also get tail-gaters but even cars get that. Do the usual – slow down and get out of the way. And if you want, can always write to TP to report the tail-gater for dangerous driving
got any links to those strait times complaints about cyclists?
Sorry, no links unfortunately. Most of them are in the Straits Times newspaper forum. You can also read up on some internet user’s opinions if you Search “bicycle” “cyclist” “cycling” in the STOMP forum. STOMP is Straits Times’ online portal for user contributions.
http://talkback.stomp.com.sg/forums/index.php
A recent discussion here: http://forums.asiaone.com/showthread.php?p=114840